The above video shows the late Steve Jobs explaining Apple’s policy in regards to location data and privacy. Now this may have all been true when he said it, but things are a little different now. What Steve explains sounds nice: Each app having to request permission for location data each and every time they want it. But what happens in the real-world is illustrated perfectly every time I launch the Facebook app on iOS:
Every single time I open the Facebook app, I see that the locations services icon is active, which means the current app is receiving location data. Even if I’ve just opened the app to see what’s new on my timeline, Facebook is accessing my location data. Why? This is absolutely not what Jobs communicated when he talked about Apple being paranoid about location privacy.
Let’s say I turn off location services for the Facebook app:
This is all fine and good if I never want Facebook to use my location data. But what if I’m posting some photos from a camping trip I’m on, and I really would like to include my location data in this post, since I think that may be of interest to my friends. I should be able to tell Facebook they can use my location data just this once, right?
So, the Facebook app is suggesting that I just turn on location services indefinitely, and I’m not given the option to temporarily allow access.
So, what happened, Apple? Why do you always have to know where I am, Facebook? Really?
Dear people who support digital rights management,
Today I purchased the third season of a show I have become a fan of recently. I went ahead and paid a premium to get it delivered in full HD. It looks great on my Apple TV, but you know what happens when I try and view the videos on my older Apple 30″ Cinema displays?
Because my 2560×1600 Apple displays use DVI instead of the DRM-riddled HDMI interface, my media refuses to play on them. Is it any wonder why people like torrents? I understand why you don’t want to play the video that I bought on an unknown device – there’s no guarantee I won’t record it to some other source and distribute it to a mass audience somewhere else. But do you think this kind of restriction is going to make me want to purchase from you in the future?
I initially thought this was going to be more of a joke than a real tutorial. I refuse to sign up for these crazy apps just to read a news article. What are your thoughts on this? Do you want everyone to know what you’ve been reading? Where do you draw the line on privacy? Let me know in the comments below.
From Mark Zuckerberg’s letter regarding Facebook’s IPO:
By helping people form these connections, we hope to rewire the way people spread and consume information. We think the world’s information infrastructure should resemble the social graph — a network built from the bottom up or peer-to-peer, rather than the monolithic, top-down structure that has existed to date. We also believe that giving people control over what they share is a fundamental principle of this rewiring.
I think the term peer-to-peer was misused here. I think I know what Mark is trying to say, but let’s keep this straight, Facebook owns every bit of content that is shared on their site. They are the master gatekeeper of information in being passed around on the site. It is not a decentralized social network. It is owned.
Rumors are flying, is the company about to go public? Should be very interesting. I’m wondering if it would be wise to invest in Facebook.
Would you invest in the massive social network?
Cool/nerdy rap about SOPA.
Um, no. Of course, that’d be too good.
“Your work is going to fill a large part of your life, and the only way to be truly satisfied is to do what you believe is great work. And the only way to do great work is to love what you do.” – Steve Jobs